Phoenix couple finally wins battle to 'develop' historic site

Phoenix, Arizona:  A battle between the City of Phoenix Planning Commission and Marilyn and Craig Milum has finally ended in victory for the couple who for years have sought permission to demolish a property they owned.

The property in question is a 'historic' three-acre parcel of land in downtown Phoenix, located at North 7th Avenue and Van Buren Street. It used to be home to a century-old laundry business, but has stood empty for a while.

The Milums, now retired, sought to sell the property in 2019 after divesting from the business. However, their plans fell apart when they learned of city restrictions that would complicate the sale. The property was tied up in escrow for two years before the sale fell through in 2023. Seeking to demolish the unused building, the Milums applied for a demolition permit, which the city denied, citing the property’s potential historic value.

The Phoenix City Council’s decision to side with the Milums came after years of back-and-forth with the city’s planning commission, which had previously suggested designating the building as a historic landmark. The council voted to reject the planning commission's recommendation, allowing the Milams to move forward with their plans to sell or develop the property.

"This has been a physically and mentally exhausting process," Marilyn Milum told ABC15 Arizona.

6 things that make your property 'historically significant'

Age of the property

The property typically must be at least 50 years old to be considered for historic designation.

Architectural significance

The property should exhibit distinctive characteristics of a particular architectural style, period, or method of construction. This could include innovative designs or the work of a notable architect or builder.

Historical significance

The property should be associated with significant historical events, activities, or people that have contributed to the development or cultural heritage of Phoenix. This could include the residence of a notable figure or a site where significant historical events took place.

Cultural or social importance

The property should reflect the cultural, social, economic, or political history of Phoenix. Buildings that played important roles in the community’s development or have ties to significant social movements can qualify.

Integrity

The property must retain its historic integrity, meaning that its essential physical features should remain intact. These features include the original design, materials, workmanship, and setting. Alterations or renovations that significantly change the property’s original appearance may disqualify it from being designated.

Neighborhood or district significance

Properties located within a historically significant district can also contribute to the area's designation. The Phoenix Historic District designation protects groups of buildings, structures, or sites that collectively hold historic significance, even if some individual properties may not meet all the criteria.